Amazon vs. Etsy:Choosing the Right E-commerce Platform

When faced with the choice of an e-commerce platform to sell your products, you may find yourself in a quandary. Especially when you have options like Etsy and Amazon, two well-known online marketplaces, the decision becomes more complex. In this article, we will explore how to select the right e-commerce platform and provide some key considerations for making that decision.


1. Define Your Product Type

First and foremost, you should clearly define your product type. Different platforms are suitable for different types of products. Etsy primarily focuses on handmade crafts, artwork, and unique items, while Amazon covers nearly all types of products. This means that if your product is handmade, unique, or artistic in nature, Etsy might be the better choice. If you are selling mass consumer goods or electronics, Amazon may be more suitable.

2. Understand Your Target Audience

Understanding your target audience is crucial. Etsy attracts specific shoppers, typically those looking for unique and handmade items. Amazon has a broad user base suitable for various audiences. Consider your target audience to determine which platform is better for engaging with them.

3. Consider Product Profit Margins

There is a significant price range difference between the two platforms. Etsy is known for its higher product profit margins because it emphasizes unique and handmade items, which often come with higher production costs and prices. On Amazon, the product range spans from inexpensive to high-end. You need to consider the price range of your products and your expected profits.

4. Evaluate the Level of Competition

The level of competition is a critical factor to consider. Etsy may have intense competition in certain niches, particularly in popular handmade crafts. Competition on Amazon is equally fierce, but the intensity varies depending on the product category. Understanding the competition you will face is essential for making a wise decision.


5. Account for Rules and Regulations

Both platforms have their own set of rules and regulations. Etsy's rules are relatively relaxed and encourage small-scale manufacturers and independent sellers. Amazon has certain regulations and requirements, especially concerning brand rights and counterfeit products. Ensuring that you understand and are willing to comply with the platform's rules is essential.

6. Emphasis on Brand Building and Community Feel

Etsy places a strong emphasis on brand building and creating a sense of community. Buyers tend to support individual seller brands. Amazon, on the other hand, focuses more on the buyer experience and convenience, and sellers are relatively anonymous. Your choice of platform should align with your brand strategy and expectations.

7. Consider Product Listing Fees and Support Services

Finally, consider product listing fees and the support services provided by the platform. Etsy usually has lower product listing fees, often based on a per-listing basis. It offers limited support services such as Etsy Ads and payment processing. Amazon's product listing fees vary based on sales volume and may include monthly subscription fees. Amazon provides a wide range of support services, such as Amazon Fulfillment and advertising services, to help sellers improve efficiency and sales.

8. How Should I Choose an E-commerce Platform?

In the end, choosing an e-commerce platform is a process of balancing the factors according to your product, target audience, and business strategy. Whether you opt for Etsy or Amazon, you should make a well-informed decision based on your specific needs to achieve successful online sales. Consider factors like product type, target audience, product profit margins, competition, rules and regulations, brand building, product listing fees, and support services. These considerations will help you make the right choice for the success and sustainable growth of your business.

Etsy Rank Tools

Start Etsy products research, get the best shops, and boost your business growth!

Trusted by 200,000+ Etsy sellers