Best Etsy Custom Gift Products

(Updated on )

Best Etsy Custom Gift Products are ranked based on total sales.

The title of the best-selling product is Personalized Name Puzzle With Pegs | New Christmas Gifts for Kids Wooden Toys Baby Shower Custom Toddler Toys First Birthday 1st Baby Gift , which came from BusyPuzzle.

💡Pro Tips: Want to beat your competition, you should know more about the Custom Gift. On the Etsy Product Research page, we offered more information about each product, such as price, tag, release date, and sales trend.

Rank	Product	Price	Total Sales	Reviews	Favorites
1	Personalized Name Puzzle With Pegs \| New Christmas Gifts for Kids Wooden Toys Baby Shower Custom Toddler Toys First Birthday 1st Baby Gift	$1.99	92,874	13,559	156,139
2	Handwriting Bracelet • Custom Actual Handwriting Jewelry • Signature Bracelet • Memorial Personalized Keepsake Gift • Mother's Gift • BH01	$25.90	71,982	10,118	184,943
3	Double Name Ring • Two Name Ring in Sterling Silver, Gold and Rose Gold • Personalized Gift For Mom • Best Friend Gift • RM75F68	$22.05	67,693	16,819	149,859
4	Personalized Name Necklace by CaitlynMinimalist • Gold Name Necklace with Box Chain • Perfect Gift for Her • Personalized Gift • NM81F91	$29.40	52,586	12,346	103,364
5	Custom Delicate Name Ring • Custom Stacking Rings • Skinny Custom Ring • Bridesmaids Gift • Baby Name Mom Gift • MOTHERS GIFT • RM21F31	$18.55	50,541	10,021	120,250
6	Personalized Wallet,Mens Wallet,Engraved Wallet,Leather Wallet,Custom Wallet,Boyfriend Gift for Men,Gift for Him, Gift for Dad	$16.98	49,463	21,814	78,122
7	Custom Name Necklace with Birth Flower,Dainty Personalized Minimalist Jewelry,Necklace for Women,Bridesmaid Christmas Gift for Her/Mom	$16.14	43,407	6,640	205,832
8	Pallet Sign / Last Name Sign / Custom Wood Sign / Established Sign / Personalized Wedding gift / Wedding Sign / 3D Sign / Family Name Sign	$24.00	41,151	7,341	100,610
9	Perfect Gift for Her • Minimalist Name Necklace by CaitlynMinimalist in Sterling Silver, Gold and Rose Gold • NH02F66	$25.90	40,213	10,266	88,128
10	Hearts Wedding Guest Book Alternative, Custom Drop Box, Unique Wooden Boho and Rustic Wedding Decor, Personalized Wedding Gift, Anniversary	$19.98	40,093	3,872	108,832
11	Personalized Bridesmaid Hangers - Wedding Hanger - Wooden Engraved Hanger - Bridal Dress Hanger - Wedding Name Hangers HG100	$8.99	38,865	16,499	63,502
12	Personalized Wine Cork Keeper \| Cork Holder \| Custom Wedding Gift \| Housewarming Gift \| Rustic Wedding \| Wood Wine Cork Shadow Box	$29.99	38,014	170	181,093
13	Personalized Name Necklace - Initial Necklace - Letter Necklace - Custom Necklace - Wife Gifts - Gifts For Mom - Minimalist- Christmas Gift	$19.17	37,239	10,226	79,240
14	Linen oven mitt (1pcs). Various colors. Linen kitchen glove. Linen kitchen mitten with heat-insulated padding. Protective cooking gloves.	$22.00	36,840	224	110,987
15	Family Necklace • Personalized Gift • Linked Circle Necklace • Custom Children Name Rings • Eternity Necklace • Mother Gift • NM30F30	$29.40	35,401	5,926	87,836
16	Custom State Necklace - Gold, Silver, or Rose Gold - Personalized - Gift for Her - Home - Best Friends - Graduation Gift - Trip Memory	$44.00	34,050	66	103,048
17	Name Earrings • Minimalist Earrings • Personalized Earrings • Personalized Jewelry • Stud Earring • Gift for Her • BridesMaid Gift • CH08F60	$18.55	32,886	7,652	74,524
18	Handwriting Jewelry • Custom Actual Handwriting Bracelet • Personalized Gift for Mom Grandma • Memorial Gift • Signature Bracelet • BH01	$27.75	30,072	212	90,505
19	Personalized Leather Keychain. Custom Leather Keychain. Monogrammed Leather Keychain. Handmade in USA. Gold and Silver Foil Available. Fob.	$6.60	29,086	7,605	63,156
20	Personalized Charcuterie Planks and Beer Flights - 4 Styles and Gift Sets Available	$55.82	28,087	4,122	71,605
21	Stackable Name Ring, dainty name ring, personalized ring with your word choice, gift for mom ring, stacking ring	$28.00	27,236	4,869	66,563
22	Gold Cake topper for Wedding, Personalized cake topper, Rustic wedding cake topper, Custom Mr Mrs cake topper, Anniversary Cake toppers	$15.99	26,708	10,667	45,857
23	14k Solid gold name necklace , Personalized Name necklace , Gold name necklace , Personalized jewelry , Personalized Gift , Christmas gift	$18.00	26,149	7,510	54,563
24	Personalized Name Blanket / minky swaddle gown knot hat bow / hospital coming home reveal outfit boy girl custom newborn baby receiving gift	$12.99	25,513	3,539	65,721
25	Personalized Name Necklaces, Personalized Name Necklaces , Script Name Necklaces, Mothers Day Jewelry , Gift for Her , Persoanlized Gift	$16.00	24,059	9,251	42,489
26	Wedding Sign, Wedding Welcome Sign, Welcome Wedding Sign Wood, Wedding Decor, Wedding Signage, Welcome Sign Wedding, Welcome to our Wedding	$58.50	23,430	4,009	57,855
27	Personalized Bridesmaid Gift, Bridesmaid Proposal Bracelet, Tie the Knot Jewelry, Custom Initial Engraving Bridesmaid Bracelet, Bridal Party	$3.99	22,828	9,755	37,098
28	Personalized Name Necklaces - Silver Name Necklace - Gold Mama Necklace - Custom Name Necklace - Name Necklace - Gift for Her Mama Mum - NN1	$9.81	22,586	6,737	46,307
29	Crystal Ring, Wire Wrapped Rings, Moonstone Ring, Jade Ring, Dainty Sterling Silver Rings, Ring, Gemstone Ring, Healing, Birthstone Stacking	$6.49	22,507	4,322	61,158
30	Personalized Gift Music Plaque Glass Art First Anniversary Gift for Boyfriend Album Cover Song Plaque, Personalize Gift with Photo, Wedding	$11.22	22,431	4,646	62,881
31	Personalized Dog Christmas Ornament w/ Name, Dog Ornament, Dog Bone Ornament, Christmas Pet Ornament, Holiday Gift for Dog Lovers, Dog Gift	$19.95	21,759	1,087	62,418
32	Custom Name Ring • Children Name Ring • Sterling Silver Ring • Personalized Gift • Gift for Her • Baby Girl Ring • Mother's Gift • RM02F18	$20.30	21,742	1,277	61,738
33	Personalized Boys Piggy Bank, Wood Gift For Kids, Neutral Baby Shower Gift, Personalized Letter Bank, Boy Nursery Decor, Wooden Piggy Bank	$34.95	21,581	5,194	48,344
34	Pallet Sign, Pallet Art, Anniversary Gift, 5th Anniversary, Custom Photo Pallet, Pallet Wall Art, Rustic Home Decor, Picture Frame, Wood	$14.99	21,267	1,851	58,407
35	Hummingbird stained glass window hangings Stained glass bird suncatcher from Ukraine Christmas gifts	$34.40	21,187	4,598	49,115
36	Plush Minky Personalized Baby Name Blanket - 30' x 40'	$19.25	21,002	8,533	35,587
37	Pet Portrait Custom and Personalized. Pet Dog Wall Art DIGITAL DOWNLOAD to Print on Poster or Canvas for gift.	$9.99	20,998	6,185	51,082
38	Personalized Name Puzzle with Animals \| Baby, Toddler, Kids Toys \| Wooden Toys \| Baby Shower \| Christmas Gifts \| First Birthday Girl and Boy	$14.75	20,984	2,851	54,255
39	Personalized Birth Flower Ring \| Custom Dainty Ring \| Everyday Statement Ring \| Stacking Ring \| Minimalist Stacking Ring \| Christmas Gift	$32.39	20,932	3,328	148,795
40	Tiny Gold Initial Necklace, Gold Letter Necklace, Gold Initial Jewelry, Bridesmaid Gift, Personalized Gold Jewelry, Custom Gold Necklace	$29.00	20,829	779	60,612
41	Custom Doormat, Housewarming Gift, Wedding Gift Ideas, Personalized Doormat, Last Name Doormat, Welcome Mat, Closing Gift, Farmhouse Decor	$16.80	20,709	406	61,478
42	Personalized Name Blanket / minky swaddle gown knot hat bow / hospital coming home reveal outfit boy girl custom newborn baby receiving gift	$12.99	20,484	3,966	49,064
43	Men's leather wallet - Personalized - Monogrammed - Bifold wallet with coin pocket - Father's day gift - For dad - Husband - Anniversary	$34.99	20,360	272	85,818
44	LIBRARY STAMP, BOOK Stamp, Custom Library Stamp, Library Of Stamp, This Book Belongs To, Custom Book Stamp, Bookplate Stamp, Library Stamps	$9.99	19,985	6,637	38,751
45	Personalized Leather Dopp Kit Bag, Valentine Gift, Leather Toiletry Bag Monogram, Mens Toiletry Bag, Leather Gift for Him - Lifetime Leather	$69.98	18,523	2,046	49,445
46	Birthstone Necklace • Bar Necklace • Silver Bar Birthstone Necklace with 'Blessed' • Birthstone Jewelry • Family Necklace • Gift for Mom	$46.00	18,427	209	57,476
47	Custom Family Necklace • Personalized Linked Circle Necklace • Interlocking Ring Jewelry • Minimalist Eternity Jewelry • Mother Gift NM30F53	$31.50	17,546	301	52,231
48	Personalized Dog Collar, Laser Engraved Metal Buckle Wedding Collar, Quick Release Buckle, Boho Cotton Voile Styles, Designer Collar	$10.79	17,515	3,778	40,683
49	Song Keychain Personalised Album Keyring Music Boyfriend Girlfriend Valentines Music Love Birthday Wedding Christmas	$8.33	17,345	2,377	44,782
50	Custom Engraved Necklace Personalized Best Friend Gifts for Women Mama Necklace Multiple Kids Names for Mom Mothers Handmade Jewelry	$13.46	17,275	6,536	35,607
51	Personalized Leather Keychain, Customized Keychain,Custom Leather Key chain,coordinates key chain longitude latitude keychain,Best Gift	$3.45	17,141	7,347	27,789
52	Custom City Ring • Cityscape Ring • Travel Ring • Skyline Ring • Statement Ring • Friendship Ring • Personalized Gift • Wedding Gift • RM41	$22.05	16,946	3,157	41,002
53	Combined Birth Month Flower Bouquet Necklace, 48 different flowers to choose, Mothers day Jewelry Gift, Best Friend, Birthday Present	$20.25	16,759	4,033	37,548
54	Housewarming Gift \| Wedding Gift \| Custom Doormat \| Personalized Doormat \| Closing Gift \| Welcome Doormat \| Front Door Mat \| Monogram Rug	$15.00	16,734	4,865	34,733
55	Personalized Bracelet for Women Gold Bar Bracelet Monogram Initial Bracelet Friendship Custom Bracelet Personalized Name Bracelet -T32-3.5	$12.60	16,707	2,646	29,383
56	Engraved Pocket Knife for Boyfriend, Personalized Knife for Husband, Hunting Knife, Custom Knife, Boyfriend Gift, Husband Gift, Pocket Knife	$14.99	16,597	7,000	27,283
57	Personalized Wall Art, Mom Gift From Daughter, Custom Mother Son Print, Mom Birthday Gift, Family Portrait, Mothers Day Gift for Mom, Prints	$24.00	16,558	4,090	36,753
58	Silky Lace Robe \| Bridesmaid Robes \| Bridal Party Robes \| Bridesmaid Gifts \| Hundred Hearts \| Bachelorette Party Gifts \| Maid of Honor Gifts	$9.99	16,452	3,507	38,350
59	Dainty PEARL Choker Necklace, Custom Gift for Her, Simple Gold Choker Necklace, Bridesmaid Gift, Gold Layered Necklace	$40.40	16,356	1,076	46,072
60	Personalized Men's Bracelet with Small Custom Beads • Leather Cord with Silver Beads • Christmas Jewelry Gift for Men Boyfriend Husband	$38.72	16,312	3,021	39,528
61	Sideway Initial Ring • Sterling Silver Ring • Stacking Ring • Custom Name Ring • Personalized Gift • Mother Gift • Baby Name Rings • RM09F39	$18.55	16,261	917	46,307
62	Custom Bridesmaid Gift, Bridal Hanger, Bridal Shower Gift, Bachelorette Party, Gift for Bride,Personalized Wedding hanger bride gift,	$13.17	16,200	3,962	36,087
63	Gifts for Mom - Combined Birth Flower Necklace - Personalized Bouquet Flower Necklace - Birthflower Necklace - Custom Mom Birthday Gift	$16.79	16,175	5,640	30,483
64	Custom Letter Necklace - Initial Necklace - Personalized Necklace - Mother's Day Gift - Personalized Gift - Gifts for Her - #LTTRF149	$40.79	16,068	3,152	34,433
65	Personalized Toy Gifts, Puzzle Piece Names, Custom Wooden Baby Name Puzzle for Toddlers, Baby Keepsake, Best Baby Gift, Toys for 18 Months	$14.40	16,024	2,813	39,341
66	Personalized Wooden Recipe Book Binder Custom Journal Cookbook Notebook Valentine's Day Bridal Shower Gift Daughter Birthday Gift Gift Moms	$18.36	15,987	2,699	73,454
67	Personalized Cutting Board - Engraved Cutting Board, Custom Cutting Board, Wedding Gift, Housewarming Gift, Anniversary Gift, Engagement	$39.00	15,745	2,530	39,426
68	Personalized Birthstone Bracelet For Women • Name Bracelet • Friendship Bracelet • Best Friend Gift • Sister Gifts • SBC-A	$12.00	15,700	2,091	40,736
69	Personalized Name Necklace • Customized Your Name Jewelry • Best Friend Gift • Gift for Her • BRIDESMAID GIFTS • Mother Gifts • NH02F49	$25.90	15,664	6,286	26,806
70	Custom Face Socks w Text, Personalized Gifts, Personalized Sock w Photo for Men & Women - Personalized Gifts for Him, Funny Pet Socks	$6.99	15,636	5,166	30,410
71	Dog Mom Jewelry, Bracelet for Dog Lover, Dog Mom Bracelet, Personalized Pet Jewelry, Pet Mom Christmas Gift	$32.00	15,563	50	47,048
72	Custom Pet Pillow \| Personalized Pillow \| Pet Memorial Gift \| Custom shaped pillow \| Dog Pillow \| Cat Pillow \| Pet Lover Gift	$14.20	15,548	2,688	49,238
73	Engraved Bracelets for Women Personalized Gifts for Her Custom Name Cuff Bracelet for Friendship Mother Bangles Christmas Jewelry -DFBR	$9.99	15,480	2,473	26,478
74	Your Pet Photo Necklace • Picture Necklace • Personalized Cat Necklace • Custom Dog Necklace • Pet Memorial Gift • Pet Lover Gift • NM41	$27.65	15,393	2,600	38,129
75	modern name necklace - name necklace - lettering necklace - wedding necklace - modern font necklace - calligraphy name necklace	$36.00	15,196	277	45,187
76	Personalized Dog Bowl, Custom Dog Bowl, Dog Gift, Puppy Gift - Small/Medium Size - Ceramic	$45.95	14,890	581	43,258
77	Personalized Initial Necklace, Anniversary gift, mom jewelry, handmade jewelry, Personalized gift, initial necklace, monogram necklace,	$40.00	14,886	1,056	42,149
78	Name beanie newborn-adult	$27.00	14,846	2,895	35,497
79	Personalized Dog Treat Jar, Dog Treat Container, Dog Gift - With Name in Gold or Silver	$43.95	14,820	36	44,840
80	Custom Roman Numerals Ring • Date Ring • Personalize Numeral Jewelry • Anniversary Ring • Stackable Engagement Ring • Promise Ring • RM03F30	$20.30	14,530	2,355	36,321
81	Custom Wood Baby Name Sign \| Letter Wall Art \| Kids Room Art \| Wall Art for Nursery \| Baby Name Sign \| Kids Room Decor \| Wooden Sign \| Boho	$10.00	14,434	2,743	34,751
82	Custom Double Birthstone Ring • Dainty Gemstone Jewelry • Sterling Silver Stacking Ring • Personalized Birthstone Ring • Gift for Her • RH05	$19.87	14,420	125	43,333
83	Engraved Picture Wallet Insert - Add Back Engraving Too - Stocking Stuffers, Gifts for Him or Her - Laser Engraved Photo Love Note Card	$20.00	14,417	2,556	35,314
84	Personalized Name Blanket / minky swaddle gown knot hat bow / hospital coming home reveal outfit boy girl custom newborn baby receiving gift	$12.99	14,366	1,719	37,919
85	personalized animal lovey, animal blanket, lovey, personalized blanket, security blanket, luvster, baby gift, personalized baby gift custom	$26.00	14,067	4,159	28,971
86	Dainty Triple Name Necklace • Children 3 Names Necklace • Custom Three Names Family Necklace • Friendship Necklace • New Mom gift • NH05F47	$32.54	13,966	2,501	34,129
87	Personalized Gift for Bride, Bridal Shower Gift, Wedding Gift, Honeymoon Pajamas, Bride To Be Gift, Custom Bridal Gift, Bride T-shirt	$27.30	13,775	3,362	30,711
88	Graduation Gift \| Custom Name Stethoscope Necklace \| Medical Student Gift \| Nurse Gift \| Doctor Gift \| Dainty Name Necklace\| Christmas Gift	$41.39	13,752	1,309	37,406
89	Set of 2 - Champagne Flutes Personalized, Wedding Gifts, Mr and Mrs Champagne Glasses, Toasting Flutes for Couples - Bride and Groom	$23.95	13,717	4,570	26,557
90	Personalized Wedding Ring Box \| Custom Acrylic Ring Box \| Engraved Ring Bearer \| Engagement Wedding Ceremony Ring Box \| Gifts for Bride	$35.99	13,650	2,576	32,923
91	Any Song Lyrics Personalised Print - Custom Vinyl Record Label Wedding - First Dance Anniversary Gift For Him Her Couple Dad Brother Paper	$16.55	13,417	1,884	34,496
92	Custom Name Necklace with Bold Curb Chain - Personalized Name Necklace - Personalized Gift - Mother's Day Gift - #PN02F189L22	$45.60	13,359	447	39,057
93	Anniversary Gift For Him, Personalized Wallet, Engraved Wallet, Gift For Boyfriend, Mens Wallet, Dad Birthday Gift, Christmas Gift For Him	$15.96	13,345	6,214	20,011
94	Sterling Silver Name Necklace, Custom Name Necklace, Christmas Gift For Her, Personalized Jewelry, Baby Name Necklace, Birthday Gift Ideas	$11.96	13,229	5,281	22,734
95	Initial Birthstone Ring • Letter Ring by Caitlyn Minimalist • Mothers Ring • Birthday Gifts • Bridesmaid Gifts • RM74F39	$18.55	13,202	2,258	32,612
96	Custom Neon Sign \| Neon Sign \| Wedding Neon Sign \| Led Neon Sign \| Name Neon Sign \| Neon Signs \| LED Sign \| Wall Decor \| Home Decor	$27.00	13,170	856	64,464
97	Dog Memorial Gift Pet Personalized Gifts for Her Pet Memorial Necklace for Dog Mom Cat Dad Pet Charm Remembrance Jewelry for Women -LCN-AP	$13.50	13,158	6,256	46,243
98	Letter Necklace by Caitlyn Minimalist • Name Necklace • Perfect for Your Minimalist Look • Gifts for Mom • NM54F77	$25.90	13,114	6,502	45,834
99	Random Wands, Custom Wands, Magic Wands, Wood Wand, Magic Wand, Wiccan Wand, Wizard Wand, Heartwood Wands	$12.11	13,110	3,238	32,410
100	Picture Air Freshener • Car Scent • Custom Car Freshie • Personlized Car Accessories • Cute Car Air Freshener	$10.99	13,070	4,151	25,974